.. _birch: Now imagine in the 1960's Fred's idea of the continuous arrival of new matter arriving in our visible universe, at exactly the rate required to balance the observed expansion. What would that universe look like? This is the view Rourke provides. He uses *de Sitter Space*, in which pairs of geodesics eventually separate exponentially, in both forwards and backwards time. It is a natural first model for a universe, one with constant curvature. New galaxies are constantly arriving in our backwards light cone, and do so highly redshifted as gamma-ray bursts. It is not new matter, spontaneously created, it has existed a very long time, but has only just now entered our visible universe. We will see it until the end of time. What if the waves we are seeing are not drammatic in-spirals of black holes, but are the result of the same modulation of gravitational waves generated by the central black holes of galaxies? Earlier in the year I submitted a proposal to this conference in Glasgow about general relativity and gravitational waves :ref:`birch`. Is there anything else? Colin Rourke, on light. The CMB and gravitational waves should be in equilibrium due to the Rees-Sciama effect? After submitting the talk, I realised the subject was a little more complex than I had hoped, requiring not just de Sitter Space, but also the model of galaxy evolution outlined in Rourke's work, where galaxies are characterised by the size of their central black holes. The release of data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument has provided ideal data to help determine the split between cosmological and intrinsic redshift. The key idea is that smaller black holes exhibit intrinsic redshift, with light coming from close to the black hole. As the central black hole and galaxy grow the redshift diminishes and is negligble in a full size galaxy. The talk was not accepted, which was somewhat of a relief. It has taken me some time to understand what is going on with galaxy spectra. I had also made the submission before I heard the very sad news that Colin Rourke had passed away. I decided I would still attend the conference, as it gave an ideal opportunity to get the latest information on gravitational wave observations and next generation detectors. I was not disappointed. .. automodule:: gotu.birch :members: